Monday, July 3, 2017

Who Designed the present National Flag?

I recently learned that a Hyderabadi Muslim woman, not Pingali, designed the tricolour Indian flag. Is it true?

3 Answers

For several decades, crores of Indian’s were led to believe that  Pingali Venkaiah from Vijayawada designed the Indian National Flag. Now,  new research by Capt. L. Panduranga Reddy proves that this is yet  another half-truth propagated by our Andhra leaders. Truth is that the  current Indian National Flag had evolved over several decades of  independence movement. Pingali Venkaiah was merely a contributor to one  of the versions of the flag. Even the flag designed by him, was not his  idea, but Venkaiah just implemented the idea of  Lala Hansraj and  Gandhiji.  Capt. L. Panduranga Reddy’s research proves that it is a  Hyderabadi woman named Suraiyya. who actually designed the final  tricolor!
Read on:

Hyderabad Woman made the National Flag
- Capt. Lingala Panduranga Reddy
President, Voice of Telangana

For many writers, the erstwhile Hyderabad state was a last legatee of  the Mughals and a feudal backward state. However, for a few it was a  peaceful state known for Ganga-Jamuna tehzeeb where people lived in  harmony. The Nizam was known for eclectic views and did not squander  state’s finances. In reality, both views are partly correct and in many  respects they are wrong. Earlier writers castigated the Nizam belittled  Hyderabad people as indolent, indulgent and ingenuous and the affluent  hedonists. On the other hand, they not only became nostalgic but also  turned apologists. They wrote about buildings, sherwanis – biryanis,  khandaan and pandaan, etc. In the process, the real contributions of  Hyderabad people were relegated to limbo of history, and the heroes were  unwept and unsung.

One such remarkable and incredible contribution was designing the  National Flag was by a woman from Hyderabad. Tomes of vernacular and  English literature attribute this to Pingali Venkaiah of Vijayawada. It  is a factoid – an assumption or speculation that is reported or repeated  so often that it becomes acceptable as truth. According to them, in  1921, All India Congress Working Committee meeting was held at Bezawada  (present Vijayawada), Venkaiah, a Congress volunteer designed a  tri-colour flag and presented to Mahatma Gandhi. Gandhi was impressed by  it and passed it on to the Working Committee. In deference to the  wishes of Gandhi, Congress had adopted it and subsequently it became the  National Flag, for which Pingali Venkaiah was hailed and Government of  Andhra Pradesh showered encomiums on him. His statue was installed at  the Tank Bund of Hyderabad along with other supposedly luminous  personalities of Andhra region.

In March 2013, Telangana protagonists organized a “Millennium March”  to Tank bund as part of agitational programmes to press for Telangana  de-merger from A.P. Some of the protagonists became restive and  demolished many statues belonging to Andhras. However, they did not  touch the statue of Pingali Venkaiah out of veneration, for they  regarded him as a nation builder. That was the esteem Venkaiah held even  amongst Telangana people. A section of media reported that  Pingali Venkaiah progeny was not only impecunious but also indigent and  also appealed to the Govt. to extend financial assistance to his  successors and the Government rightly obliged.

Be that as it may, the official history of Congress reads altogether  different. The All India Congress Committee Commissioned Bhogaraju  Pattabhi Seetaramaiah to write a detailed Congress history. Accordingly,  he wrote authentic history of Congress. He writes that – the issue  of National Flag was first time ever discussed in the annual conference  of the Indian National Congress held at Calcutta in 1923. However, the  Home Rule League movement which was started by both Bal Gangadhar Tilak  and Annie Beasant in 1916, had already designed a flag and propagated it  as the National Flag. Subsequently, the Home Rule League was merged  with the Congress. However, the Congress appointed a sub-committee to  finalise the flag for India. On this Committee, a noted artist,  Avinindranath Tagore was included. The Committee never met and finalized  the Flag.

Sitaramaiah further succinctly writes that the Congress included  ‘Charaka’ to the earlier Home Rule League Flag and adopted. It was in  1931, original red colour in the Home Rule League Flag was replaced with  Ochre colour (Bhogaraju Pattabhi Seetaramaiah, Congress Charitra, All  India Congress – Allahabad, Andhra Patrika Printing Press, Chennapuri,  1935, p.207). It should be noted that the History of Congress is a  ponderous book of 870 pages and has 86 annexures. Seetaramaiah was a  knowledgeable senior national Congress leader from Krishna district of  Andhra Pradesh. To this very district, Pingali Venkaiah belonged.  However, Seetaramaiah did not make mention of Venkaiah’s name, not even  once in this book.

Bal Gangadhar Tilak started the Home Rule League confined mainly to  Maharashtra and Karnataka in April 1916, whereas Annie Beasant founded  her Home Rule League in September 1916. Activities of both league  consisted of carrying out propaganda for the Congress – League agenda of  political reforms following the Lucknow Pact. In the year 1917, the  33rd session of the Congress was held at Calcutta, and the first woman  President Annie Beasant (Dec. 26th to 29th). As Annie Beasant became the  President of AICC, she merged the Home Rule League along with its  tri-colour in the Congress. That means, tri-colour came into vogue in  1917 whereas the Working Committee of Congress met at Bezawada only in  1921. In this meeting, Pingle Venkaiah supposed to have presented  tri-colour to Mahatma Gandhi. The contemporary newspapers of that period  both vernacular English did not make any mention of the flag.

It was in 1957, the Government of India while celebrating the century  celebrations of 1857, the first war of independence, had decided to  compile a book on the freedom fighters of India and solicited the  services of noted historian Prof. Tarachand of Allahabad University. He  produced four volumes of authentic history of freedom movement citing  primary sources. Curiously enough his book also does not make a mention  of Pingali Venkaiah and his much orchestrated tri-colour flag.
Be that as it may, another erudite English historian Trevor Royle in  his “The Last Days of the Raj” writes that the National Flag was made by  Badruddin Tayabji’s wife.

He writes “By one of those contradictions which run through  India’s history, the national flag was designed by a Muslim, Badr-ud-Din  Tyabji. Originally the tricolour was to have contained the  spinning-wheel symbol (charka) used by Gandhi but this was a party  symbol which Tyabji thought might strike the wrong note. After much  persuasion Gandhi agreed to the wheel because the Emperor Ashoka was  venerated by Hindu and Muslim alike. The flag which flew on Nehru’s car  that night had been specially made by Tyabji’s wife.” (Trevor Royle, The Last Days of the Raj, Cornet Books, Hodder and Stoughton, London, pg. 217)

Tyabji was an ICS officer in the Prime Minister’s office in 1947. He  was known for erudition and scholarship and his wife’s name was  Suraiyya. She was none other than niece of Sir Akbar Hydari of  Hyderabad. Her wedding was performed at Hyderabad city. Thus the Indian  tricolour was made by a woman from Hyderabad, but history does not  record the contribution of Hyderabad people as was done in the case of  Maulvi Allauddin, the first 1857 martyr who was transported for life to  Kalapani, Andamans and Abdul Hasan Safrani a Hyderabadi who coined  Jaihind slogan.

Dramatist Shakespeare is right: “when beggars die, there are no comets seen; the heaven’s blaze from the death of princes”.

Source : The truth about who designed the Indian National Flag

Crowly Mathew Arackal
The formal information says "The National Flag of India was designed by Pingali Venkayya and adopted in its present form during the meeting of Constituent Assembly held on the 22 July 1947, a few days before India's independence from the British on 15 August, 1947". Pingali Venkayya was an Indian freedom fighter.

But a news in Indian Express in 2013 says:

"Our national flag was designed by a Hyderabadi Muslim woman by the name of Suraiya Tayyabji and not by Pingali Venkaiah as is widely believed, according to Voice of Telangana president Capt. L Panduranga Reddy.

At a press conference here on Monday, Panduranga Reddy said the popular belief was that in 1921 the All India Congress Committee meeting was held at Bezawada (Vijayawada) wherein Pingali Venkaiah, a Congress volunteer designed a tri-coloured flag and presented it to Mahatma Gandhi.
Gandhi was reportedly impressed by the design and passed it on to the working committee. In deference to the wishes of Gandhi, the Congress adopted the flag and subsequently it went on to become the national flag. But the truth is that the national flag was designed by a Hyderabadi Muslim woman, Suraiya Tayyabji.

In order to substantiate his claims Capt. Panduranga Reddy said that the AICC authorised historian Bhogaraju Pattabhi Seetaramaiah on the issue of national flag, who has written that the issue of national flag was for the first time discussed in the annual conference of  the Indian National Congress held at Calcutta in 1923.

However, the Home Rule League movement which was started by  Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Annie Beasant in 1916, had already designed a flag and propagated it as the national flag.

After the merger of Home Rule League in Congress, a sub-committee was appointed to finalise the national flag, but the committee never met and the Congress included a charkha in the Home Rule League flag and adopted it as the national flag.

It was in 1931, that the original red colour in the Home Rule League flag was replaced with the ochre colour and that the charkha was replaced by Ashoka’s Dharma Chakra.

However, Seetaramaiah did not make any mention of Pingali Venkaiah’s name, not even once in his book.  Moreover, the resolutions adopted during 1921 All India Congress Committee meeting held at Bezawada makes no mention of the meet adopting a resolution on the acceptance of the national flag design prepared by Pingali Venkaiah, he claimed.

Even in the book published on the freedom struggle by noted historian Tarachand “Freedom Struggle of India” published in 1957, there was no mention of Pingali Venkaiah having designed the national flag.

“Moreover, the book published on the occasion of centenary year of Congress party in 1985 has  no mention of Pingali Venkaiah designing the national flag”, he said. It was Prof. Sarojini Regani of Osmania University, who in her hagiography, “Highlights of the Freedom Movement in Andhra Pradesh” published by the state government in 1972 had written about Pingali Venkaiah designing the national flag. However, she does not cite any primary source to substantiate her assertion.

The sample prepared by Suraiya Tayyabji was approved on July 17, 1947, he claimed and added that English historian Trevor Royle in his book “The Last Days of the Raj” has written that the national flag was actually designed by Badruddin Tayabji’s wife Suraiya Tayabji".

'Hyderabadi Muslim woman, not Pingali, designed Tricolour'

Personally I do not think we can prove or disprove the claims at this time especially when we cannot get any first hand information on the issue.

No comments: