Monday, October 20, 2014

Analysis of Criminal Background, Financial, Education, Gender and other details of Winners


​Haryana Election Watch (HEW) and Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) have analysed the self-sworn affidavits of all the 90 winners in the Haryana Asembly 2014 Elections. English Report is attached with the mail and the Hindi Report would be uploaded on the website subsequently.

Final Party Positions
Party
Won
Bharatiya Janata Party
47
Indian National Lok Dal
19
Indian National Congress
15
Haryana Janhit Congress (BL)
2
Bahujan Samaj Party
1
Shiromani Akali Dal
1
Independents
5
Total
90
Criminal Background
  • Winners with Criminal Cases: Out of the 90 winners, (10%) winners have declared criminal cases against themselves. Out of 88 winners analysed duringHaryana Assembly 2009 elections15 (17%) winners had declared criminal cases against themselves. There has been a decrease in the percentage and number of winners in Haryana with declared criminal cases.
  • Winners with Serious Criminal Cases: 5 (6%) winners have declared serious criminal cases in their affidavits. Out of 88 winners analysed during 2009 Haryana Assembly elections13 (15%) winners have declared serious criminal cases. There has been a decrease in the percentage and number of winners in Haryana with declared serious criminal cases.
  • Party wise Winners with Criminal Cases: (11%) out of 47 winners from BJP, 1 (7%) out of 15 winners from INC, 2 (11%) out of 19 winners from INLD and 1 (50%) out of 2 winners from HJC(BL) have declared criminal cases against themselves in their affidavits.
  • Party wise Winners with Serious Criminal Cases: (4%) out of 47 winners analysed from BJP, 1 (5%) out of 19 winners from INLD, 1 (7%) out of 15 winners from INC and 1 (50%) out of 2 winners from HJC(BL) have declared serious criminal cases against themselves in their affidavits.
Inline image 1
​Financial Background
  • Crorepati WinnersOut of the 90 winners analysed, 75 (83%) are crorepatis. Out of 88 winners analysed during Haryana Assembly 2009 elections66 (75%) winners were crorepatis.
  • Party-wise Crorepati Winners: 40 (85%) out of 47 winners from BJP14 (93%) out of 15 winners in INC13 (68%) out of 19 winners in INLD, both HJC(BL)winners and all five Independent winners have declared assets worth more than Rs. 1 crore.
Inline image 2
  • Chances of Winning for Crorepati Candidates: The chances of winning for a crorepati candidate in the Haryana Assembly 2014 elections are 13% whereas for a candidate with low assets (
  • Candidates Asset Position and Chances of Winning: 57 winners (63%) occupy top three highest asset positions in their respective constituency. 24(27%)winners have the highest declared assets in their constituency. 19 (21%) winners have the second highest declared assets in their constituency and 14 (16%) winners have the third highest declared assets in their constituency.
Inline image 3
  • Average Assets: The average assets per winner for Haryana 2014 Assembly Elections are Rs. 12.97 crores whereas the average asset for each candidate was Rs. 4.38 croresIn 2009 the average assets per winner of 88 winners analysed was Rs. 6.71 crores
​​
Inline image 4
  • Party-wise Average Assets: Among major parties, the average assets per winner for 47 BJP winners is Rs 10.50 crores19 INLD winners have average assets ofRs.13.01 crores, 15 INC winners have average assets worth of Rs.12.45 crores and 5 Independent winners have average assets of Rs. 13.95 crores.
  • High Asset Winners*: 7 winners have declared more than Rs.50 crores worth of assets. The top three winners with highest assets are given below:
S.No.
Name
District
Constituency
Party Name
Movable Assets (Rs)
Immovable Assets (Rs)
Total Assets (Rs)
PAN Given
1
Vipul Goyal
Faridabad
Faridabad
BJP
62,95,89,881
43,67,52,731
1,06,63,42,612
 106 Crore+
Y
2
Kuldeep Bishnoi
Hisar
Adampur
Haryana Janhit Congress (BL)
64,74,38,575
15,38,28,109
80,12,66,684
 80 Crore+
Y
3
Renuka Bishnoi
Hisar
Hansi
Haryana Janhit Congress (BL)
64,74,38,575
15,38,28,109
80,12,66,684
 80 Crore+
Y
​​
*Total Assets includes income of self, spouse and dependents.
  • Winners with High Liabilities: A total of 15 winners have declared liabilities of Rs. 1 crore and above. Out of these 15 winners, 5 have declared liabilities of Rs. 10 crore and above. Five winners with the highest declared liabilities are as given below:

S.No.
Name
District
Constituency
Party Name
Total Assets(Rs)
Liabilities (Rs)
PAN Given
1
Vipul Goyal
Faridabad
Faridabad
BJP
1,06,63,42,612
 106 Crore+
43,94,29,153
 43 Crore+
Y
2
Ravinder Machhrouli
Panipat
Samalkha
IND
31,70,57,573
 31 Crore+
14,45,34,753
 14 Crore+
Y
3
Smt. Rohita Revari
Panipat
Panipat City
BJP
8,97,92,177
 8 Crore+
10,45,63,000
 10 Crore+
Y
4
Kuldeep Bishnoi
Hisar
Adampur
Haryana Janhit Congress (BL)
80,12,66,684
 80 Crore+
10,40,02,005
 10 Crore+
Y
5
Renuka Bishnoi
Hisar
Hansi
Haryana Janhit Congress (BL)
80,12,66,684
 80 Crore+
10,40,02,005
 10 Crore+
Y
  • Winners with High Income as declared in ITR*: 7 winners have declared total annual income of more than Rs. 1 crore. The top three winners with highest declared total annual income are given below:

S.No.
Name
Party Name
Constituency
District
Total Assets (Rs)
The financial year for which the last income tax return has been filed by winner
Total income shown by winner in ITR (Self+Spouse+Dependent) (Rs)
Self income shown by winner in ITR (Rs)
1
Vipul Goyal
BJP
Faridabad
Faridabad
1,06,63,42,612
106 Crore+
2012-2013
4,42,17,962
4 Crore+
2,27,24,431
2 Crore+
2
Chaudhary Abhay Singh Chautala
INLD
Ellenabad
Sirsa
43,13,01,267
43 Crore+
2013-2014
2,16,74,730
2 Crore+
2,16,34,800
2 Crore+
3
Capt. Abhimanyu Singh
BJP
Narnaund
Hisar
77,40,61,458
77 Crore+
2012-2013
2,05,20,331
2 Crore+
93,08,412
93 Lacs+
*Total income includes income of self, spouse and dependents
  • Winners who have not declared Income Tax Details*: 12 (13%) winners out of 90 have not declared income tax details.* Some winners may be exempted from filing Income Tax Returns

Inline image 5Inline image 6

Comparative Analysis of Assets of Re-elected Winners
  • Number of Re-elected winners: Number of re-elected winners analysed in the Haryana Assembly 2014 elections is 21
  • Average Assets of re-elected winners in 2009The average assets of re-elected winners in 2009 was Rs. 4 crores
  • Average Assets of re-elected winners in 2014: The average assets of re-elected winners in 2014 is Rs. 13.80 crores
  • Average growth in assets of re-elected winners from 2009 to 2014: The average assets growth of re-elected winners is Rs. 9.80 crores i.e. by 245%.
Inline image 7

Other Background Details
  • Education Details of Winners: winner has declared that he is illiterate29 (32%) winners have declared that have an education qualification of 12th pass or below (not including winner who has declared that he is illiterate) while 57 (63%) winners have declared having an educational qualification of graduate or above
Inline image 8
  • Age Details of Winners: 44 (49%) winners have declared their age to be between 25 to 50 years while 46 (51%) winners have declared their age to be between 51 to 80 years.
Inline image 9
  • Gender Details of Winners: Out of 90 winners analyed, 13 (14%) winners are women while 77 (86%) winners are men. In 2009, out of 88 winners analysed, 8 (9%) winners were women
​Regards,
Media and Journalist Helpline

+91 80103 94248
Email: adr@adrindia.org
Maj.Gen Anil Verma (Retd)
Head
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
011 4165 4200,
+91 88264 79910
adr@adrIndia.org,
anilverma@adrindia.org
Prof Jagdeep Chhokar
IIM Ahmedabad (Retd.)
Founder Member,
National Election Watch, Association for Democratic
Reforms
+91 99996 20944
jchhokar@gmail.com
Prof Trilochan Sastry
IIM Bangalore
Founder Member,
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
+91 94483 53285
trilochans@iimb.ernet.in
--
Association for Democratic Reforms
T-95A, C.L. House, 1st Floor,
(Near Gulmohar Commercial Complex)
Gautam Nagar
New Delhi-110 049

M: +91 8010394248 
T: +91 11 41654200
F: 011 4609 4248